STR Marketplace vs PSL Source: comparing two ways to buy or sell an NFL PSL

STR Marketplace and PSL Source take two different approaches to the same problem: getting a PSL from one owner to another safely. One is built and approved by the team itself; the other is an independent broker working across teams. Here's how they compare, based on what each publicly discloses.

Last verified: July 21, 2026, from strmarketplace.com and the Dallas Cowboys Seat Option Marketplace (cowboys.strmarketplace.com), one of STR's team-specific sites, and from pslsource.com. Terms vary by team site (for STR) and can change, so always confirm directly before transacting.

Quick verdict

STR Marketplace operates a separate, team-branded website for each of its roughly 18 NFL partners, and every listing and transaction is reviewed and approved by the team itself. PSL Source is a single independent platform covering 19 NFL teams, with no direct buyer commission and a broker-agent model that steps in once an offer is accepted.

Choose STR Marketplace if: your team runs an official marketplace through them and you want the team's direct sign-off on the deal. Choose PSL Source if: you want a single account across multiple teams and no direct buyer commission line item, and you're comfortable with a broker managing the deal after acceptance.

Comparison table

Fees

STR Marketplace raised its seller fee to 12% ($250 minimum) in 2026, disclosed during the transaction rather than upfront on the listing; its buyer fee applies on top of the purchase price. PSL Source charges a 10% seller commission ($250 minimum) and no direct buyer commission, though a buyer there still covers the team's own transfer fee, any available ticket invoice cost, and a 3.5% surcharge if paying by credit card or PayPal.

Product

STR Marketplace runs a separate, team-branded website for each partner, with its own login per team, an interactive map at the section level, and a message center for buyer-seller contact. PSL Source runs as a single platform across its 19 supported teams, also with a section-level map, and shifts to a broker-agent model once an offer is accepted: a PSL Source representative verifies both parties and manages the paperwork by phone or email rather than through in-platform negotiation tools.

Negotiation & transfer

Both platforms use offers and counteroffers rather than fixed pricing. STR Marketplace gives sellers a 48-hour window to respond, and a pattern of missed offers can get a listing pulled. PSL Source's window is 72 hours. After acceptance, STR's transfer runs through buyer, seller, and the team's ticket office directly, while PSL Source assigns a dedicated agent to verify both parties and manage the paperwork before releasing funds.

Best for

• A transaction with the team's direct backing at every step: STR Marketplace, if your team is a partner.
• A single account across multiple teams instead of a separate site per team: PSL Source.
• No direct buyer commission line item: PSL Source, though team transfer fees and card surcharges still apply.
• A private transfer to family, or due to death or divorce: STR Marketplace, for a fixed price depending on the team.
• Market data like deal scores and price trends before you list or offer: PSL Source.

Looking for a third option?

If you'd rather negotiate directly in real time, with published fees and support available 24/7, PSL Scout covers 19 NFL teams under one account without a broker or team-approval step in between.

---

Sources: strmarketplace.com (Who We Are, Work With Us, How It Works) and cowboys.strmarketplace.com (FAQs, How to Sell, How to Buy, Contact); pslsource.com (Home, FAQs, Our Guarantee, About Us). Reviewed July 21, 2026. STR Marketplace's terms are set independently per team site and may differ from the Cowboys site referenced here. The 12% seller fee and 2026 fee increase for STR Marketplace are confirmed internally by the PSL Scout team rather than published on strmarketplace.com. If you have documentation of updated fees or policies for either platform, contact us and we'll update this page.